Today’s post comes from one of our members, Troy Hinchco. Troy felt compelled to write this letter to the editor “after sitting up most nights hearing the big boys crowing about instability in small business”.
___________________________________________________
Open Letter to the Australian Consumer – at large.
I write this letter as someone whose only regular exposure to Letters to the Editor are those which my wife reads out to me because she thinks they will touch a chord, amuse or infuriate me.
This letter is not a direct reaction to one of those letters, it is instead to ask Australian consumers to consider a small thing when making purchasing decisions in the future.
The Australian consumer – and I know this because I am one – is being given messages of security, assurance and confidence in their purchases of goods and services from some of the various industries biggest heavyweights. Corporations are being caring, sharing, and responsibly warning you of the insecurity of dealing with Australia’s ‘little guys’. Gerry Harvey politely points out the plight of the small operator in retail, as do a myriad of other comparable business celebrity’s offering comment about ‘the security of larger, trusted brands, businesses and services’ as we struggle through this economic pressure point. Normally directly or indirectly in reference to their own business.
The greatest threat that the courting of consumers by large businesses, regardless of industry, is that in times like these when consumers are at their most susceptible to influence from the comforting arms and scripted promises of ‘safer’ corporates, they can do the greatest damage to Australia’s community of small businesses.
A small businesses reason for creation differs slightly from industry to industry, for the most part the emergence of smaller businesses is normally because of their ability to service a portion of the market better, more economically or with slightly more customer-centric differences from that of the larger corporate brethren.
The larger corporates whose creation story may evoke tales of the humble start-up and the emergence from their own challenges and trials does this because it encapsulates the basic elements of the Australian dream – the dream of going out alone, being your own boss, making something for yourself.
But all corporate businesses whether started from a double garage in Sutherlandshire in Sydneys southern suburbs 100 years ago or being created with a Big Bang approach in the 90’s with the heavily funded launch through IPO’s and big hitting investors – all larger businesses detune their customer focus at some point. At some stage in their evolution being driven by striving for absolute customer satisfaction at a transaction by transaction level is replaced by measured acceptable failure levels benchmarked against other ‘comparable’ corporates around the world. Standard and ongoing application of the 80/20 rule optimising returns on investment and the resultant dumming down of their service offer to fringe, niche and ‘non-ideal’ customers gives new businesses who are built around those needs, a reason to exist.
In times like these though the larger businesses make noises about their changed service commitment as they react to tougher times and struggle themselves to achieve key financial objectives. If they do adopt new customer focus, will it stay, is it something that has come about as a short term grab for business they ultimately don’t think ‘suits’ their model for optimised profitability? Probably not.
Is there a place for large the corporate ? Yes, of course, they are vital to our economy as booming entities of business able to tap into resources unlike anything comparable from the realms of small business collectively or not. They employ large numbers of hardworking Australians, they contract and sub-contract out millions of dollars of business to small businesses and trades people every year. They are, where suits and is congruent to their branding, philanthropic to a fault. We simply need big business and we are better for them.
Do I buy from large corporates? Of course, we shop at Coles or Woolworths for 70% of our grocery and consumable products , we buy petrol from the local Caltex, because it’s accessible and might even be a reasonable price but, we also make a point to buy as much fruit and vegetables from our local Market, meat from a local butcher and bread from a local bakery as we can.
Are we doing this because the produce is a higher quality, the service a million times better and because they know our names? Sometimes yes to all of these – and - sometimes no to all of them as well.
We do this because we know that when we compare a local, national and global market with a mix of large corporate entities and smaller Mum and Dad businesses we as consumers and members of a greater community are given the better range of options in all areas of goods and service.
If you are buying a product, a service or even advice – take the time to compare some of the smaller operators in that field – quite often they may be cheaper, faster, more open to offering a slightly customised product based directly around your needs - but - greater still there is a chance that you will be dealing with someone who will pay themselves last as they strive to fulfil a service that you will be satisfied with, a service that you might talk to others about and may ultimately lead to growth in business for them through word of mouth. They won’t be investing in broad brush advertising on the backside of a yellow bus just to satisfy a ‘brand recall’ matrix some guru from America wrote about years ago. Their money and time and dreams are fully committed to their business and their own fulfillment of the Australian dream – not to retire at 38, drink French champagne and eat Russian caviar – but to be their own boss, to prove themselves to themselves as capable and contribute to the countries emergence from the global economic struggle.
On behalf of Australian small business owners, employees and suppliers I implore you not to accept the corporate route to quality product and service as your default, as this would make the media and high level corporate crowing about instability in small business a self foreseeing prophecy. Instead allow us at least the chance to stack up and compete for your business. All we ask is the opportunity to be considered.
Thank you.
Troy Hinchco
Very Small Business Owner
(TIAG Australia Pty Ltd, Select Home Products)